Do Locals Leave Eau Claire to Find Love? Indeed They Do.

Mike Paulus

Recently, the Star Tribune ran an essay from local UW-Eau Claire English professor Katie Vagnino entitled, Lonely in Eau Claire: Why I started commuting to Minneapolis for romance.

The essay details the quest of a local 33-year-old serial monogamist who had hoped to find a soulmate “hiding in the cornfields of bucolic western Wisconsin,” but ... hasn’t.

She has, however, had much better luck in the Twin Cities – that handsome Midwestern siren who’s been sucking young professionals and greasy-haired indie rock bands out of Eau Claire for decades. Using dating apps like Tinder, Vagnino discovered a much wider array of datable men on the other side of the St. Croix with “far fewer Green Bay Packers jerseys.”

She’s careful to point out she’s not anti-Wisconsin, per se. She does enjoy Eau Claire’s apartment rental rates:

Don’t get me wrong, there are things I enjoy about Wisconsin — who wouldn’t like paying $450 for a one-bedroom apartment? But the culture took some getting used to.

She says the local single men responding to her online dating profile generally followed certain patterns. Most had kids. Most had been married. None of this turned her off, and she said the men she’s met are polite, attractive, and intelligent. However, as she points out ...

Sports fandom or even fanaticism was pretty much a given, as was outdoors enthusiasm. Camping, fishing and hunting appeared to be the activities for which most of these men sought companionship. Given my proclivity for urban creature comforts and fear of firearms, I figured it was time to test the wisdom of Paula Abdul and see if opposites really did attract.

She didn’t say if any of the men she’s dated appreciate Paula Abdul references from 1988. I’m betting not many. (I’d also wager against the effectiveness of quoting MC Skat Kat whilst wooing local thirty-somethings.)

As far as the sports and hunting stuff – fair enough. You’ll definitely get more of that around here than in places like New York or Boston – the writer’s ol’ stompin’ grounds.

Obviously, Vagnino has found herself un-attracted to her locally based “opposites.” She was looking forward to meeting men “less neurotic and less metrosexual” than what she was used to on the East Coast. And while this is apparently what she’s found, she’s also discovered very little common ground.

She also claims, “most of these guys had never lived outside of Wisconsin and couldn’t understand why anyone would want to.”

A certain amount of defensiveness...

A certain amount of defensiveness (that I’d classify as “a lot”) bubbles up in reaction to Vagnino’s essay. I’m not alone – it’s certainly the popular sentiment I’ve seen in local Facebook threads discussing her commentary, as well as in comments on the Star Tribune’s website. But really, I know she’s not trying to speak for everyone. She’s talking about her own likes and dislikes, and you can’t fault her for that. I’d rather not listen to local dudes discussing fantasy football for hours on end, either. (That’s a torture one sees lumbering across both gender and relationship boundaries.)

So, I wouldn’t take it too personally, men of Chippewa Valley. She’s just not that into you.

I will say this, however. Having grown up in Eau Claire, and having attended school at the very same University by which Vagnino is employed, the “football lovin’ cornfield dweller who loves to shoot guns” is not the stereotypical man I’ve encountered. There are many of these guys, and they are often great fellas, but I can’t imagine they represent an overwhelming majority of the local dating pool. I think plenty of local men own cats, listen to NPR, and like watching BBC shows on Netflix.

That said, I’m straight, married, and not trying to find such a man, so I have no idea where they hang out en masse. Vagnino has far more experience here. I may very well be wrong. 

At the end of the day I just really want my neighbors to be happy in both love and life, so I want to believe this area is home to the kind of guy Vagnino wouldn’t mind serial monog-ing. Perhaps local guys searching for ladies into “Russian literature, sushi, Etta James, and pinot noir,” as Vagnino is, just don’t do a lot of online dating? I don’t know.

We spend a lot of time talking about local culture, local development, and the local art/music/writing scenes, but the area’s dating and relationship scene is a pretty important part of the Chippewa Valley Puzzle. Pointing out our low diversity in the dating pool is not necessarily an insult, but it’s absolutely not something we’d paint on the “Welcome to Eau Claire” sign.

Ultimately, Vagnino is not alone in this, and she brings up some pretty valid observations worthy of our discussion. So please ... discuss.

Press and hold the up/down arrows to scroll.